Compare Breast Pumps / Comparison Chart
How to choose the perfect pump
| Ameda Purely Yours | Ameda Purely Yours with Carryall | Ameda Ultra | Cimilre M1 | Cimilre S2 Hospital Grade | Spectra 3 | Spectra Dew 300 | Spectra Dew 350 Hospital Grade | Unimom Allegro | Unimom Forte | |
| Pump Type | Double Electric; comes with 2 breastkits | Double Electric; comes with 2 breastkits | Double Electric; comes with 2 breastkits | Double Electric; comes with 2 breastkits | Double Electric; comes with 2 breastkits | Double Electric; comes with 2 breastkits | Double Electric; comes with 2 breastkits | Double Electric; comes with 2 breastkits | Single Electric, comes with 2 kits | Double Electric; comes with 2 breastkits |
| Can also be used as a single electric | Can also be used as a single electric | Can also be used as a single electric | Can also be used as a single electric | Can also be used as a single electric | Can also be used as a single electric | Can also be used as a single electric | Can also be used as a single electric | Can be expanded to a double electric | Can also be used as a single electric | |
| Country of Origin | USA | USA | USA | South Korea | South Korea | South Korea | South Korea | South Korea | South Korea | South Korea |
| Certifications | USA FDA and European CE approved as a pesonal breast pump | USA FDA and European CE approved as a pesonal breast pump | USA FDA and European CE approved as a pesonal breast pump | USA FDA and European CE approved as a pesonal breast pump | USA FDA and European CE approved as a hospital grade breast pump | USA FDA and European CE approved as a pesonal breast pump | USA FDA and European CE approved as a pesonal breast pump | USA FDA and European CE approved as a hospital grade breast pump | USA FDA and European CE approved as a pesonal breast pump | USA FDA and European CE approved as a pesonal breast pump |
| Price | P11,000 | P15,000 | P19,000 | P7,800 | P10,800 | P4,900 | P5,200 | P7,400 | P5,950 | P6,950 |
| Pump Motor Volume | 6.5" x 5" x 2" | 6.5" x 5" x 2" | 7" x 5" x 2" | 4.7’” x 2.6” | 7.5” x 7.3” | 6.5" x 5" x 3.5" | 8" x 5.5" | 8" x 5.5" | 3.5" x 3.5" x 2.5" | 6.5" x 6.5" x 4.5" |
| Pump Motor Weight | 1 pound | 1 pound | 1.1 pounds | 1 pound | 3 pounds | 3 pounds | 4 pounds | 4.4 pounds | .6 pound | 3.75 pounds |
| Warranty on Pump Motor | 1 year | 1 year | 1 year | 1 year | 1 year | 1 year | 1 year | 1 year | 6 months | 1 year |
| Ameda Purely Yours | Ameda Purely Yours with Carryall | Ameda Ultra | Cimilre M1 | Cimilre S2 Hospital Grade | Spectra 3 | Spectra Dew 300 | Spectra Dew 350 Hospital Grade | Unimom Allegro | Unimom Forte | |
| Package inclusions | Pump motor, 2 breastkits including narrow neck bottles extra pair of valves | Ameda Purely Yours package + tote bag, cooler bag with 3 cooling elements and 4 additional bottles | Ameda Purely Yours package + tote bag, cooler bag with 3 cooling elements, 4 additional bottles, M/L flange sizes, manual pump handle and car adaptor | Pump motor, 2 wide neck breastkits, 2 wide neck bottles, 2 backflow protectors, 2 valves | Pump motor, 2 wide neck breastkits, 2 wide neck bottles, 2 backflow protectors, 2 valves | Pump motor, 2 wide neck breastkits, 2 wide neck bottles, 2 valves, 2 sets backflow prevention filters | Pump motor, 2 wide neck breastkits, 2 wide neck bottles, 2 valves, 2 sets backflow prevention filters | Pump motor, 2 wide neck breastkits, 2 wide neck bottles, 2 valves, 2 sets backflow prevention filters | Pump motor, 1 breastkit including 1 narrow neck bottle, 1 silicon massager, 1 bottle stand | Pump motor, 1 breastkit including 1 narrow neck bottle, 1 silicon massager, 1 bottle stand |
| Power source | A/C or 6 AA batteries (1.5v), car adaptor sold separately | A/C or 6 AA batteries (1.5v), car adaptor sold separately | A/C or 6 AA batteries (1.5v), car adaptor included | A/C or rechargeable battery | A/C only | A/C only | A/C only | A/C only | A/C or rechargeable battery | A/C only |
| Closed system (milk, moisture and outside air does not enter the pump) | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Safe for sharing | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Strength | 280 mmHg | 280 mmHg | 280 mmHg | 320 mmHg (as single) | 300 mmHg | 320 mmHg | 300 mmHG | 350 mmHg | 260 mmHg (as single) | 290 mmHg |
| What you can control | Speed and suction strength | Speed and suction strength | Speed and suction strength | Letdown mode and expression mode, speed and suction strength | Letdown mode and expression mode, speed and suction strength, lighting | Suction strength | Suction strength. | Suction strength. | Suction strength (speed decreases as suction strength is increased) | Suction strength |
| Bottle Type | Narrow-neck, PP material | Narrow-neck, PP material | Narrow-neck, PP material | Wide-neck, PP material | Wide-neck, PP material | Wide-neck, PP material | Wide-neck, PP material | Wide-neck, PP material | Narrow-neck, PP material | Narrow-neck, PP material |
| Ameda Purely Yours | Ameda Purely Yours with Carryall | Ameda Ultra | Cimilre M1 | Cimilre S2 Hospital Grade | Spectra 3 | Spectra Dew 300 | Spectra Dew 350 Hospital Grade | Unimom Allegro | Unimom Forte | |
| Key Benefits | Lightweight | Lightweight | Lightweight | Lightweight | Hospital – grade | Strong | Strong | Hospital – grade | Lightweight | Strong |
| Battery option (6 AA batteries) | Battery option (6 AA batteries) | Battery option (6 AA batteries) | Rechargeable | Letdown button | Comfortable | Comfortable | Comfortable | Rechargeable | Comfortable | |
| Speed and suction can be adjusted | Speed and suction can be adjusted | Speed and suction can be adjusted | Letdown button | Speed and suction can be adjusted | ||||||
| Sound | Slight beep | Slight beep | Slight beep | Soft whirr (trrr... trrr...) | Soft whirr (trrr... trrr...) | Quiet hum | Quiet hum | Quiet hum | Soft whirr (trrr... trrr...) | Quiet hum |
| Ameda Purely Yours | Ameda Purely Yours with Carryall | Ameda Ultra | Cimilre M1 | Cimilre S2 Hospital Grade | Spectra 3 | Spectra Dew 300 | Spectra Dew 350 Hospital Grade | Unimom Allegro | Unimom Forte | |
| Best for moms who | Pump at least 2x a day or exclusively pump | Pump at least 2x a day or exclusively pump | Pump at least 2x a day or exclusively pump | Pump at least 2x a day or exclusively pump | Pump at least 2x a day or exclusively pump | Pump at least 2x a day or exclusively pump | Pump at least 2x a day or exclusively pump | Pump at least 2x a day or exclusively pump | Pump occassionally such as 1x a day | Pump at least 2x a day or exclusively pump |
| Will carry their pump a lot | Will carry their pump a lot | Will carry their pump a lot | Will carry their pump a lot | Will carry their pump a lot | ||||||
| Has no access to electricity when pumping | Has no access to electricity when pumping | Has no access to electricity when pumping | Has no access to electricity when pumping | Has no access to electricity when pumping | ||||||
| Number of parts to clean in each breastkit (including bottle) | 1 – bottle, 2 – flange, 3 – valve, 4 – diaphragm | 1 – bottle, 2 – flange, 3 – valve, 4 – diaphragm | 1 – bottle, 2 – flange, 3 – valve, 4 – diaphragm | 1 – bottle, 2 flange, 3 valve, 4 – backflow protector (set of 3) | 1 – bottle, 2 flange, 3 valve, 4 – backflow protector (set of 3) | 1 – bottle, 2 flange, 3- valve | 1 – bottle, 2 flange, 3- valve | 1 – bottle, 2 flange, 3- valve | 1 – bottle, 2 flange, 3 valve, 4 – backflow protector (set of 3) | 1 – bottle, 2 flange, 3 valve, 4 – backflow protector (set of 3) |
| Nipple fit | Spectra default size is 28mm - nipple tip diameter like a 25 centavo coin. >If nipple diameter is around a 10 centavo coin, purchase the silicon massagers. >If diameter is around P1-P5 coin, replace Spectra kits with an Ameda M/L or XL/XXL flange system for P1150. Unimom default size is 27mm - nipple tip diameter like a 25 centavo coin > Silicon massagers are included for smaller nipples >If diameter is around P1-P5 coin, replace Spectra kits with an Ameda M/L or XL/XXL flange system for P1150. Ameda 25mm - nipple tip diameter less than a 25 centavo coin > Ameda 22.5 mm inserts or 21 mmm flexishields are available for smaller nipple sizes. > Purchase Ameda M/L or XL/XXL flanges for P1150 | |||||||||
| Babymama summary: | Easy to operate, lightweight | Easy to operate, lightweight | Easy to operate, lightweight | Rechargeable, portable and strong | Hospital – grade, your best bet to help increase supply | Affordable and strong | Affordable, strong and very comfy | Affordable, strong and very comfy | Lightweight and comfortable; alternative to a manual pump | Affordable, strong and very comfy |